Sitemap

Millennials have no morals: What I learned from the murder of Phil Masterson

7 min readNov 24, 2021

In the fall of 2011, my friend’s body was found in a wooded area on a Lake Erie island, covered in a tarp and missing his clothes. But what happened to him was no mystery.

Press enter or click to view image in full size
Georgeanne Masterson’s favorite picture of her son.

I’ll never forget the phone call I answered, mid-morning on a weekday, in the fall of 2011. It was the day after Labor Day, and I’d spent the weekend trying to ignore my looming sense of dread. I blamed my pregnant brain — I was eight months along — and got back to the daily grind. Until I got the call.

“There’s an article in the Plain Dealer this morning — Phil Masterson? Weren’t you friends with him?”

I remember hearing a sudden burst of static, the kind that happens in old-school horror movies before the killer cuts the victim’s phone line. Looking back, I know that was probably my imagination. But the next words I heard were not.

“He was killed on Put-in-Bay this weekend.”

What do you mean, killed? How? By a drunk driver? I hung up the phone and found out I was late to the media circus — everyone else had found out two days earlier, when I was still at a cabin in Northern Michigan with virtually no cell phone service. Phil Masterson was killed in a “senseless beating,” and a suspect, Zachary Brody, had already been named. Since I was the…

--

--

Ashley Herzog
Ashley Herzog

Written by Ashley Herzog

New account. I’m still a professional journalist, novelist, and radio host. And Catherine’s mom.

Responses (12)